educational

Adverse Effects or All An Act?

In 1986 in the small town of Renton, Washington, adult motion picture theaters faced a monumental challenge: the Mayor of this city of 32,000 suggested to Renton City Council members that it enact a zoning ordinance to deal with adult entertainment venues.

Their response? A prohibition against adult theaters operating within 1000 feet of any residential zone, single or multiple family dwelling, church, park or school. After considerable legal haggling, the result was a determination that the ordinance was a valid response to "dangerous" problems created by adult theaters and "satisfies the dictates of the First Amendment." But How?

Time, Place, Manner Regulation
Constitutional law dictates that "content-neutral" time, place, manner regulations are acceptable only if they are "designed to serve a substantial governmental interest" without unreasonably limiting alternative avenues of communication. (475 U.S. 41, 46-47). More simply put, the District Court found that the City Council's "predominate concerns" were with the secondary effects of adult theaters, and not with the content of adult films themselves. Even if "a motivating factor" in enacting the ordinance was to restrict respondents' exercise of First Amendment rights the ordinance would be invalid, apparently no matter how small a part this motivating factor may have played in the City Council's decision. 748 F.2d, at 537

Substantial Government Interest
The Court found that a city's interest in preserving the quality of life in the city was proper. In fact, it is proper for Renton to regulate adult theaters by dispersing them in the outskirts of the city. Since Renton did not summarily ban adult theaters from operating, the Renton City Ordinance was considered valid. So it's not surprising that when the ACE Miami Adult Legal Conference assembled in March of this year, discussion surrounding the future difficulties facing adult business owners centered around this pivotal secondary effects case.

According to Brad Shafer, a veteran First Amendment lawyer, "secondary effects is now the doctrine that the Supreme Court and the federal courts and state courts around the country now utilize as a basis to regulate any type of adult business and any type of regulation." However, this type of reasoning is flawed for a number of reasons.

In Flanigan Enterprises, Inc. v. Fulton County, an ordinance was enacted which prohibited the sale of alcohol in nude dance clubs. According to Steve Youngelson, the attorney for Flanigan Enterprises, Inc., the case revolved around the secondary effects studies the county conducted before enacting these ordinances. Police and Department of Planning officials studied alcohol consumption in dance clubs as they related to property value and crimes in the surrounding areas. What is problematic is that Fulton County relied on Los Angeles and San Antonio based studies completed in the 1970's.

The result? They were unable to find any correlation between the two. So, in order to substantiate the claim that there really did exist a secondary detrimental effect, the county looked elsewhere, effectively abandoning the results of their own studies. Using studies conducted in Los Angeles and San Antonio, cities which found a detrimental correlation. What is problematic is that Fulton County relied on Los Angeles and San Antonio based studies completed in the 1970's. While Renton suggests that if a county does not have it's own studies, it may use those of other cities in similarly situated areas, the difficulty arises in finding any similarity between these two cities nearly three decades apart. Reasonable? Stretching it.

Although the Supreme Court has ultimately decided that legislatures may reasonably rely upon these studies, the reasonableness of these studies needs to be reconsidered. Until we reach a time when the Court can admit these studies are flawed, adult businesses and their owners must maintain a vigilante watch on the legal maneuverings of police and prosecutors on a rampage.

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

opinion

Breaking Down HB 805 and How it Affects the Adult Industry

North Carolina House Bill 805 was enacted July 29, after the state legislature overrode Governor Josh Stein’s veto. The provisions that relate to the adult industry, imposing requirements for age verification, consent and content removal, are scheduled to become effective Dec. 1. Platforms have until then to update their policies and systems to comply with the new regulations.

Corey D. Silverstein ·
opinion

Staying Compliant With Payment Standards Across Europe and Australia

So, you’ve got your eye on international growth. Smart move. No matter where adult-industry merchants operate, however, one requirement remains consistent: regulatory compliance. This isn’t just a legal checkbox — it’s a critical component of keeping payments flowing and business operations intact.

Jonathan Corona ·
opinion

How to Avoid Copyright Pitfalls When Using Music in Adult Content

When creating an adult video, bringing your vision to life often means assembling just the right ingredients — including the right music. However, adding music to adult content can raise complex legal and ethical issues.

Lawrence G. Walters ·
opinion

New Visa Rules Adult Merchants Need to Know

In December 2024, I shared an update on the upcoming rollout of Visa’s Acquirer Monitoring Program, also known as VAMP. The final version went into effect in June, and enforcement will begin in October. With just a month to go, now is the time to review what’s changing and how to stay compliant.

Cathy Beardsley ·
profile

Dan Leal Talks Balance, Business and Daily Rituals

“We were in a big field, and I hopped off a little ledge to cut through some grass, and my knee just gave out,” he explains. “I thought it was my calf because I’d torn my calf muscle back in December, but I had an MRI that confirmed a torn ACL.”

Jeff Dana ·
profile

Sarah Illustrates Spins Chill Vibes Into Viral Fame

Lounging in her sunny SoCal backyard in between content shoots, with her hair swept into a no-fuss ponytail and the sun dappling her shoulders, Sarah Illustrates looks every bit the hot mom next door — because, well, she is. The kind of mom who bakes fresh bread on the weekends, juggles dance recitals and baseball games, and delights in life’s simpler joys, like family time and trips to Target.

Jackie Backman ·
opinion

WIA Profile: Lainie Speiser

With her fiery red hair and a laugh that practically hugs you, Lainie Speiser is impossible to miss. Having repped some of adult’s biggest stars during her 30-plus years in the business, the veteran publicist is also a treasure trove of tales dating back to the days when print was king and social media not even a glimmer in the industry’s eye.

Women in Adult ·
opinion

Fighting Back Against AI-Fueled Fake Takedown Notices

The digital landscape is increasingly being shaped by artificial intelligence, and while AI offers immense potential, it’s also being weaponized. One disturbing trend that directly impacts adult businesses is AI-powered “DMCA takedown services” generating a flood of fraudulent Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) notices.

Corey D. Silverstein ·
opinion

Building Seamless Checkout Flows for High-Risk Merchants

For high-risk merchants such as adult businesses, crypto payments are no longer just a backup plan — they’re fast becoming a first choice. More and more businesses are embracing Bitcoin and other digital currencies for consumer transactions.

Jonathan Corona ·
opinion

What the New SCOTUS Ruling Means for AV Laws and Free Speech

On June 27, 2025, the United States Supreme Court handed down its landmark decision in Free Speech Coalition v. Paxton, upholding Texas’ age verification law in the face of a constitutional challenge and setting a new precedent that bolsters similar laws around the country.

Lawrence G. Walters ·
Show More